Scotland’s Parliamentarians Hot On Catalonia – Ice-Cold On Tibet

Scottish SNP leader, Nicola Sturgeon with Sinofortone exec Peter Zhang Richard Heygate advisor to China Railway No.3

Image: GCR News

Scottish politician @ChristinaSNP issues a jointly signed public appeal for the European Union to take action against the suppression of democracy and human rights in Catalunya.We totally support that statement and respect her and fellow signatories for issuing it.

However why is the party, of which she is a member, seemingly dedicated to national freedom so selective with its condemnation? Surely wherever a people are violently denied democratic freedoms and human rights it would be a reasonable expectation for the Scottish National Party (SNP) to express solidarity and oppose such oppression?

Unfortunately such principled consistency looks to be absent from Ms McKelvie’s party. As evidenced by its comparative silence on the plight of the Tibetan people, who since 1950 endured a genocidal assault upon their national and cultural identity.

Where then are the public declarations from the SNP supporting Tibet? Has Ms McKelvie or her colleagues released an official statement condemning the Chinese government for its brutal suppression of Tibetans and violently denying them the most basic of freedoms?

Being a member of a Scottish Parliamentary group on Tibet, which Ms McKelvie declared on Twitter as a defense against the charge of double-standards, is not the issue. What’s troubling is the selectivity applied by her party. Proud to issue bold statements of support for Catalunya, but silent on Tibet. Such a contradiction demanded to be exposed and challenged, especially when the likely reason for the hypocrisy is political sensitivity on the matter of 10 billion UK pounds of Chinese investments, and trade with Scotland.

We wonder, were the Spanish authorities investing the same amounts of cash into the Scottish economy if Ms McKelvie, the SNP and Scottish Parliamentarians would have publicly called upon Donald Tusk of the European Union to oppose  the dark excesses of the Spanish authorities against the people of Catalunya?

Published by:


A not-for-profit network of individuals who support justice, human rights and independence for the peoples of Tibet and East Turkestan. Based in a number of countries subscribers are actively engaged voluntarily and are wholly supportive and active on the issue of Tibetan independence. We are not a hierarchical organization, there are no offices, nor do we receive or pay salaries, we do not make money from merchandising sales, and rely upon the kindness of individual donors to finance ongoing research and campaigns.

Categories Appeasing China, News Item, TibetTags , , , , ,